Jewelry Store & Fine Watches in Sarasota, FL

Carats Fine Jewelry And Watches

Family owned and operated luxury jewelers, Carats offers the finest in designer jewelry and Swiss timepieces to Sarasota, FL costumers. Our distinctive collection features brand name bridal jewelry, top-quality diamonds, pearls, and timepieces.

We offer new and pre-owned jewelry and watches from the world’s premiere design houses, as well as one-of-a-kind estate pieces.

Carat Store | Carats Fine Jewelry And Watches

Fine Watches

The hallmark of any piece of fine jewelry is how beautiful and intricate the design is. The greater the attention to detail, the more unique and revered the pieces is. Nowhere is this truer than when it comes to the world of designer watches. We invite you to come visit our jewelry store in Sarasota, FL and discover for yourself why we think branded watches are such an important aspect of fine jewelry that we put the word watches in our name.

Buy, Sell or Trade Jewelry & Fine Watches

Bring in your diamond, jewelry or time piece to our jewelry store in Sarasota, FL to be purchased by us or apply it towards a trade-in to upgrade your current piece. We can also update your old into new by reworking it into a custom design that is only limited to your imagination.

Get instant cash for your jewelry

No appointment needed

Professional thorough evaluation of each piece

"WOW! I took in my engagement ring in to be repaired and cleaned. I am BLOWN AWAY by the results. My ring has never looked better. It is by far shinier/cleaner now than when I first got it! The service is outstanding... The staff friendly and knowledgeable but the results speak for themselves. I will never go anywhere else!!!"
- Audra Mega
"I recently had the pleasure of working with the outstanding team at Carats Fine Jewelry & Watches. Melissa and the team are very knowledgeable and creative when it comes to selection or design. Customer Experience is A+++ and they delivered on what they promised."
- Christopher Peacock - Franchise Partner | Sarasota
"I have a ring that has massive sentimental value and wouldn’t take it anywhere else for repair and polishing. Extremely friendly staff, very competent jeweler, reasonable wait times and good pricing. Highly recommended, even for your most precious pieces!"
- Susan Byrne
"My favorite Jewelry store in SRQ. Always friendly staff and fair prices without having to haggle much."
- Brian Wacnik
"Melissa is one great person and her rock star jewelers are amazing. All her staff is very friendly and knowledgeable. I brought Melissa a smokey quartz stone that my daughter found while gem mining in NC and they made it into a amazing peace of jewelry that my daughter will have for a life time. They made me the best Dad this Christmas !!! Thanks for all your help !!"
- Rob DeForge
"Small and family owned is what you want in a luxury watch store. Go to Carats and don’t go on price for luxury watches ... go to Carat’s based on trust, service and reputation. I took my purchase from a big NYC 5th Ave Flagship Store which had significant problems due to the NYC store not honoring warranty. Carats immediately fixed all my Rolex’s issues, and made it look better and function as well as brand new!"
- Tom Harris
"Melissa is a real jewelry pro. I was in the store recently and found the staff friendly and relaxed. They offered to polish my old ring for me and it came out better than I ever remember it looking. Carats is my only source for bling now. I tell everyone I know about Melissa's store. Keep up the great atmosphere Melissa and Co!"
- Brett Allred

Read more reviews on